Wednesday, January 6, 2016

Politician Sets New Record

How many lies can fit into a speech?
Let's see:
1. "(The USA is) the only advanced country on Earth that sees this kind of mass violence erupt with this kind of frequency. It doesn't happen in other advanced countries. It’s not even close."

Truth: the US, when adjusted for population, is well behind the top 5 countries in mass shootings. All of these top 5 have somewhat or very restrictive firearms policies.

2. "There’s a general consensus in America about what needs to be done"

Truth: there is no "general consensus" about what needs to be done. Of random people I've discussed the topic with- NOT known supporters of my political views- no more than 1 in 3, at most, say anything about further restricting firearms access to the general US populace. More intensive scrutiny of incoming immigrants and better US mental health care are mentioned much more frequently.

3. "We don't need to be talking past one another. But we do have to feel a sense of urgency about it. In Dr. King’s words, we need to feel the “fierce urgency of now.” Because people are dying. And the constant excuses for inaction no longer do, no longer suffice."

Truth: the obvious insinuation is that violent crime is rising in the US. The FACT is that the most recent FBI data (2014) shows the exact opposite. I don't like graphs, but this makes the point at a glance: 

4. "To prove that the vast majority of Americans, even if our voices aren’t always the loudest or most extreme, care enough about a little boy like Daniel to come together and take common-sense steps to save lives and protect more of our children."

Truth: this is a two-fer, in which the President uses an emotional appeal to suggest that if you don't support his political agenda, you don't care about the lives of children, and adds the lie that his suggestion are "common sense" (which I'm pretty sure he wouldn't know if it bit him). This president may lie more per sentence than even Bill Clinton.

5. "I believe in the Second Amendment. It’s there written on the paper. It guarantees a right to bear arms. No matter how many times people try to twist my words around -- I taught constitutional law, I know a little about this."

Truth: "weapons that were designed for soldiers in war theaters don't belong on our streets." In other words, President Obama "believes in the Second Amendment", he just doesn't believe US citizens should have modern firearms. 
2012 Issues.

6. "We all believe in the First Amendment, the guarantee of free speech, but we accept that you can’t yell “fire” in a theater. We understand there are some constraints on our freedom in order to protect innocent people. We cherish our right to privacy, but we accept that you have to go through metal detectors before being allowed to board a plane. It’s not because people like doing that, but we understand that that’s part of the price of living in a civilized society."

Truth: no matter how much US citizens may dislike it, airlines are private entities, and are entitled to whatever restrictions they wish to place on those who choose to use their service. Now, whether any US governmental agency should be allowed to dictate what policies must be enforced on all airline customers is a different question altogether, but the airlines themselves could enforce any restriction they wanted, so long as it was equally applied to all of their clients, without any infringement on Constitutional rights.

7. "If a father wants to teach his daughter how to hunt, he can walk into a gun store, get a background check, purchase his weapon...A violent felon can buy the exact same weapon over the Internet with no background check, no questions asked."

Truth: this is one of the most blatant lies in recent history. This has not been legal since before Al Gore invented the internet. Selling modern firearms through the mail to anyone but licensed dealers except in very controlled circumstances ALSO requiring documentation has been illegal for almost 50 years. You get to choose whether you believe the President is willfully lying, or is ignorant of something I've known since before I was a teenager. Current law showing that firearms purchased from out of state and shipped must be received by a firearms dealer (FFL) is here.

8. "A recent study found that about one in 30 people looking to buy guns on one website had criminal records -- one out of 30 had a criminal record. We’re talking about individuals convicted of serious crimes -- aggravated assault, domestic violence, robbery, illegal gun possession."

Truth: if you read carefully, and think about it, you'll see that the President suggests one in 30 people looking at this website have a violent or disqualifying criminal record, but THAT'S NOT WHAT HE SAID. Most of you reading this have a "criminal record", even if it's only for speeding. You've probably looked at one or more gun sites, too, you criminal.

9. "So we’ve created a system in which dangerous people are allowed to play by a different set of rules than a responsible gun owner who buys his or her gun the right way and subjects themselves to a background check."

Truth: repetition of previous blatant lie.

10. "Senator John McCain introduced a bipartisan measure to address the gun show loophole."

Truth: there is no "gun show loophole". Requirements for licensed gun dealers are the same whether they are selling from their shop or at a show. Here are the ATF requirements, which the President is either blissfully ignorant of, or is lying about:  It would be statistically improbable that almost every so-called gun control advocate would be ignorant of the truth, so the obvious conclusion is that they are all lying.

11. "Some of you may recall, at the same time that Sandy Hook happened, a disturbed person in China took a knife and tried to kill -- with a knife -- a bunch of children in China. But most of them survived because he didn’t have access to a powerful weapon. We maybe can’t save everybody, but we could save some."

Truth: the suggestion is being made that firearms are very dangerous weapons, the most dangerous weapons an ordinary citizen might have access to. Not a claim that stands up to scrutiny when comparing a projectile with from about 190 up to about 2400 ft-lbs of energy (common firearm caliber projectile energy at the muzzle) with any car. A Smart Car FourTwo with a single passenger, traveling at only 30 mph has 60,500 ft-lbs of energy.

12. "we know that background checks make a difference. After Connecticut passed a law requiring background checks and gun safety courses, gun deaths decreased by 40 percent -- 40 percent. Meanwhile, since Missouri repealed a law requiring comprehensive background checks and purchase permits, gun deaths have increased to almost 50 percent higher than the national average. One study found, unsurprisingly, that criminals in Missouri now have easier access to guns."

Truth: the Connecticut violent crime rate has been declining since at least 2009, with an uptick due to the 2012 Newtown killings. The rate of decline from 2012-2013 is very similar to the rate from 2010-2011.

The President conveniently "forgot" to give any authentic sources for his fuzzy facts.

13. "And the evidence tells us that in states that require background checks, law-abiding Americans don’t find it any harder to purchase guns whatsoever."

Truth: Analysis of NICS flags (denials to purchase) in 2009 show about 94% of the flags were false. Described another way, out of 71,010 initial denials, 77 people were prosecuted for attempting to illegally purchase a firearm.

14. "The evidence tells us that in states that require background checks, law-abiding Americans don’t find it any harder to purchase guns whatsoever. Their guns have not been confiscated. Their rights have not been infringed."

Truth: in California, in particular, laws passed in 2013 and 2015 have resulted in seizures of legally purchased firearms, sometimes due to complaints filed by parties who had other disputes with the firearm owners. Veteran Rick Bailey had his firearms seized after a neighbor filed a harassment charge against Bailey as a result of Bailey's complaints to the city about the neighbor's waste disposal business.
The 2015 law allows local authorities to seize guns for up to 21 days while a determination is made as to whether the gun owner is fit to possess them.

15. "When it comes to an inherently deadly weapon -- nobody argues that guns are potentially deadly -- weapons that kill tens of thousands of Americans every year, Congress actually voted to make it harder for public health experts to conduct research into gun violence; made it harder to collect data and facts and develop strategies to reduce gun violence. Even after San Bernardino, they’ve refused to make it harder for terror suspects who can’t get on a plane to buy semi-automatic weapons."

Truth: according to the FBI, there were 8,124 murders with firearms in the US in 2014. There were 721 justifiable homicides.
According to the CDC, in 2014 there were 586 accidental shootings and 21,334 suicides with firearms. This is a grand total of 30,765 deaths caused with a firearm in 2014. Oddly enough, this is less than the number of traffic fatalities (33,736) and considerably less than poisoning fatalities (42,032). and even a bit less than deaths from unintentional falls (31,959), but the President refuses to call for more "common-sense" regulations of motor vehicles, deadly chemicals and ladders. Where is the outrage?

Those "terror suspects" the President references include US National News Anchors who travel worldwide. You know- to report stories. Because that's their job.

16. "Number one, anybody in the business of selling firearms must get a license and conduct background checks, or be subject to criminal prosecutions."

Truth: anyone who sells functional modern firearms (made after 1899) must have a license and comply with state background check law, which either requires a per-transaction background, or that the purchaser hold a firearm permit which required a background check, depending on the state. President Obama does not specifically state that businesses selling firearms currently may not possess FFLs, but he does insinuate it.

17. "We’re also expanding background checks to cover violent criminals who try to buy some of the most dangerous firearms by hiding behind trusts and corporations and various cutouts."

Truth: trusts can be set up to make firearms purchase and transfer easier and less hassle, but a violent criminal (any felon or someone convicted of domestic violence) may still not legally purchase or use any modern firearm.

18. "We're going to require firearms dealers to report more lost or stolen guns on a timely basis."

Truth: FFLs are required to report lost or stolen firearms within 48 hours.

19. "We’re going to ensure that federal mental health records are submitted to the background check system, and remove barriers that prevent states from reporting relevant information."

Truth: what the President is describing is a violation of current Federal law. "Mental health records" are protected just like any other medical information, and the fact that the President wants to take your confidential information and put it in government databases should alarm everyone. The Department of Health and Human Services has already clarified that health providers are allowed to give patient information to " law enforcement, family members of the patient, or other persons, when you believe the patient presents a serious danger to himself or other people".

Some veterans are already losing their firearms or are being denied firearms purchases because of VA reporting, such as veteran John Arnold being entered into NICS as ineligible after he suffered a stroke. President Obama wants to expand this reporting, which is already clearly causing problems for some fully competent lawful Americans.

20. "Nearly two in three gun deaths are from suicides."

Truth: this is absolutely true, and it's nice that President Obama managed to say at least one true statement during this recitation of lies, insinuations, and half-truths. Mr. Obama does not, however, mention that only half of suicides are committed with firearms. What about the rest, Mr. President?

So, there you have it. There are even more untrue or, at best, deceptive statements in what President Obama said, but I'm just too tired to point out any more, and if you're honest, you've already been convinced that the President is deliberately lying to the American people. He does want to restrict your firearms freedoms, he does not want you to have capable modern firearms, and he is perfectly willing to take your confidential medical information and put it in a Federal database, which we have seen even this year is fully susceptible to access by hackers. Because screw freedom.


Holly said...

Excellent post full of good documentation and well thought out arguments.

Cargosquid said...

16. anyone who sells functional modern firearms (made after 1899) must have a license and comply with state background check law, which either requires a per-transaction background, or that the purchaser hold a firearm permit which required a background check, depending on the state.

You might want to clarify that some states do not require a background check at all instead of leaving it as "comply with state background check law."

Other than that....this is GREAT!

J.R.Shirley said...

Holly, thank you.

Cargosquid, thanks for reading and commenting. To my knowledge, every state requires either an instant check or that the purchaser hold a license which required a background check initially. If you have a source showing exceptions to that rule, I'll be happy to update and correct. :-)